At the end of the month, the invoices land on your desk and you see that production cost more than you expected. The total amount is clear, but it does not tell you which line, which shift or which product drove it up. Operating costs can only be used for decision-making once you can relate them to what you produced and sold in the same period. A calculation based on data measured directly on the shop floor will help you do this, and it will also show you where costs can be reduced.
What are operating costs?
Production runs every day, and every day something costs you money. You have to pay for the hall, people’s work, consumed materials and energy, as well as for regular maintenance and machine repairs. Operating costs are exactly these ongoing costs of running the business over a given period, such as a month, a quarter or a year. They are also called operating expenses, and you will often come across the abbreviation OPEX. If you only know them as one total for the whole company, you know how much you spent, but not where and why.
A company buys a new press. The purchase itself is a capital expenditure, abbreviated as CAPEX, meaning a one-off expenditure on an asset that serves the company for years. Such an investment enters costs gradually through depreciation, which is the part of the asset’s price that the company charges to costs for each year of its use. An expensive machine therefore does not burden the results of a single month with its full price, but with a small amount over many years. The operator’s wages, the electricity the press consumes and its regular maintenance, on the other hand, are operating costs.
What is included in operating costs in manufacturing?
When you break down monthly production costs, you will find that they consist of six groups. For each of them, it is worth knowing how it behaves when production volume changes and whether you can assign it to a specific product. Variable costs rise and fall with the number of units produced, while you pay fixed costs in the same amount during both full and weaker production. Direct costs can be assigned to a specific product or order, while indirect costs, also called overhead, serve several products at once and are allocated among them.
| Cost group | What it includes | Fixed / variable | Direct / indirect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material consumption | Raw materials, semi-finished products and packaging | Variable | Direct |
| Auxiliary materials | Variable | Indirect | |
| Energy | Electricity and compressed air for running machines | Variable | Indirect |
| Heating, ventilation and lighting of the hall | Fixed | Indirect | |
| Personnel costs | Operators’ wages and social contributions | Fixed in the short term | Direct |
| Wages and social contributions of supervisors, maintenance, warehouse and administration staff | Fixed | Indirect | |
| Maintenance and repairs | Regular machine servicing | Fixed | Indirect |
| Repairs after breakdowns and spare parts | Mostly fixed | Indirect | |
| Rent, insurance, services and fees | Hall rent and insurance | Fixed | Indirect |
| External services, such as cleaning and transport | Mostly fixed | Indirect | |
| Taxes and fees | Fixed | Indirect | |
| Depreciation | The part of a capital expenditure charged to costs for the year | Fixed | Indirect |
What, on the other hand, is not included in operating costs?
Operating costs do not include the purchase of a machine, a hall or any other long-term asset, because that is an investment. Similarly, an upgrade that increases a machine’s performance is usually an investment. Nor do they include interest on loans and income tax, which are reported separately in the income statement. Interest relates to the way the company finances its operations, not to what production itself costs. If you added it to operations, two halls working equally well would appear to have different costs just because of one hall’s loan.
How to calculate operating costs step by step
➡️ Total operating costs for the period
We will demonstrate the calculation using a model medium-sized manufacturing company for one month. The first step is to add up all groups of operating costs for the same period.
| Item | Amount per month |
|---|---|
| Material consumption | €210,000 |
| Energy | €38,000 |
| Personnel costs | €96,000 |
| Maintenance and repairs | €14,000 |
| Rent, insurance, services and fees | €22,000 |
| Depreciation | €20,000 |
| Total operating costs | €400,000 |
From the table, you can see that running the company cost €400,000 for the month and that materials account for more than half. This shows you which group has the greatest impact on the result. However, the total alone does not tell you whether this is a lot or a little. A month in which you produced more will naturally be more expensive, and that does not necessarily mean worse performance. The boundary of the period can also mislead you, for example when an energy invoice arrives late and is recorded in the wrong month. That is why you should always relate the total to what was produced and sold in the same period.
➡️ Operating costs as a share of revenue
The first ratio is the share of revenue, which shows what part of the money earned is consumed by running the business itself.
Operating costs as a share of revenue = operating costs / revenue × 100
The model company generated €460,000 in revenue for the month.
€400,000 / €460,000 × 100 = 86.96%, rounded to 87%
The result means that approximately 87 cents of every euro of revenue goes to operations. Interest and income tax are still paid out of the remaining approximately 13 cents, and only then is there a profit. This indicator is most valuable when you track it month by month. If it rises, operations are becoming more expensive faster than revenue is growing, and it is time to look for the cause. However, the selling price also changes the share. If you raise product prices, it drops, even though nothing has changed in the hall. The share of revenue therefore shows that something is happening, but it still does not tell you where the cause lies.
➡️ Operating costs per good unit
Closer to production is the calculation per unit. It shows how much operating cost falls on each product you can sell.
Operating costs per unit = operating costs for the period / number of good units
The model company produced 82,000 units in the month. Of these, 2,000 failed inspection, so 80,000 are good.
€400,000 / 82,000 pcs = €4.88 per unit produced
€400,000 / 80,000 pcs = €5.00 per good unit
Defective units consumed material, energy and machine time, but cannot be sold, so their costs are spread across the good units. If you divide by all units produced, production looks cheaper than it really is. The result can mislead you if you produce several types of products. The amount of €5.00 is an average for the whole company, in which a simple part and a complex part come out as equally expensive. A company-wide average is therefore suitable for tracking trends over time, not for creating a price list.
➡️ Machine hour cost
The last calculation goes down to the level of a single machine. The machine hour rate tells you how much one hour of machine production costs, and it is used when pricing orders.
Machine hour cost = annual fixed costs of the machine / annual operating hours + variable costs per operating hour
The fixed costs of the model machine are €54,000 per year. Variable costs are €6 for each operating hour. The plan assumes 3,600 operating hours per year.
€54,000 / 3,600 h + €6 = €15 + €6 = €21 per hour
Due to downtime, the machine actually produces for only 2,700 hours.
€54,000 / 2,700 h + €6 = €20 + €6 = €26 per hour
The actual hour is therefore €5 more expensive, which is approximately 24% more than in the calculation. The company may thus be selling below its actual costs without being able to tell from its own numbers. The number of actual operating hours is related to availability, one of the components of OEE, the indicator that evaluates overall equipment effectiveness. Availability tells you what share of the planned time the machine actually worked. The lower it is, the fewer hours the same fixed costs are spread across, and the more expensive the machine hour becomes.
➡️ Other ways to calculate operating costs
→ Cost per unit at a different production volume shows how the cost of one unit changes when you produce less or more.
Cost per unit = fixed costs / number of good units + variable cost per unit
→ Break-even point tells you how many units you need to sell for revenue to cover all costs. It is useful when deciding on a new line or order.
Break-even point in units = fixed costs / (selling price per unit − variable cost per unit)
→ Loss per hour of downtime expresses how much the company loses for every hour the line is down and the lost production can no longer be made up. It helps determine which breakdown to address first.
Loss per hour of downtime = number of units the line would produce per hour × (selling price per unit − variable cost per unit)
→ Cost of a specific order or product replaces the company-wide average. It is based on the material, machine time and labor consumed by that particular product.
Order cost = material for the order + operator hours × hourly wage + machine hours × machine hour cost
→ Cost per employee or per square meter is used when comparing operations. However, it can be misleading for differently equipped lines.
Cost per employee = operating costs for the period / number of employees
Cost per square meter = operating costs for the period / floor area of the operation in m²
Why do calculation results often not match reality on the shop floor?
⚠️ Some downtime is missing from the records
The planned number of hours is often used in the machine hour calculation, because nobody knows exactly how many hours the machine actually produced. The operator records operating time and downtime in the report only at the end of the shift, usually from memory and rounded to quarter hours. Short stops after which the line restarts on its own do not make it into the report at all. The result is a higher number of operating hours than the machine actually worked, and therefore an underestimated machine hour cost.
⚠️ Defects are recorded too late
Some defective units are not detected at the machine, but only during final inspection or after a customer complaint. They enter the records days or weeks later, often without information about the shift and the order or product they came from. The month in which they were produced then shows more good units and a lower cost per good unit than is actually the case. Moreover, without information about where they originated, it is impossible to determine whether the defects are caused by one machine, one setting or one type of material.
⚠️ Production misses the plan for no known reason
The number of units produced at the end of the shift shows that the machine did not meet the plan. However, it does not show whether it was down longer, ran slower than its specifications allow or produced units that failed inspection. Each of these losses has a different cause and requires a different measure. Without distinguishing between them, the cost per good unit cannot be reduced in a targeted way, because you do not know which loss increases it the most. In practice, the long breakdown usually gets addressed because it is the most noticeable, even though the machine may actually be losing more time by running slowly.
⚠️ Maintenance is not charged to a specific machine
Invoices for spare parts and servicing are usually charged to a cost center, which is a part of the company whose costs are tracked together, for example the entire press shop. From the accounts, you therefore know how much maintenance of the press shop cost, but not how much a specific press cost. An older machine with frequent repairs and a new trouble-free machine receive the same share in the calculation. Maintenance in the machine’s fixed costs is then an average for the entire cost center, which will not help you decide whether it is worth continuing to repair the older machine or replacing it with a new one.
⚠️ Energy is allocated only by floor area
The company measures energy only at the hall’s supply point and allocates the invoice among the lines according to the floor area they occupy. A line with a quarter of the area thus gets a quarter of the energy costs. If there is a furnace or a press on it, it may actually draw significantly more. An energy-intensive product then appears cheaper than it is, and the difference is added to the costs of other products. Moreover, the monthly invoice does not show when consumption was highest and how much energy was used during breaks and shutdowns.
⚠️ The numbers are in separate spreadsheets
Production has its own reports, maintenance its own records, energy is tracked by facility management, and material prices and wages are in the accounting system. By the time a monthly overview for management is put together from these sources, weeks go by and the overview describes a situation that no longer applies. In addition, departments often work with different numbers for the same period, so it first has to be clarified which ones are valid. When you then change something on the line, you do not have a reliable baseline from before the change to compare the result with. You therefore do not know whether the measure actually reduced costs.
How to measure and reduce operating costs?
✅ SCADA collects actual operating hours
SCADA is a supervisory system for technology that collects and displays data from machines in one place. Most of today’s machines are controlled by a PLC, an industrial control computer that knows whether the machine is running, stopped or in a fault state. On an older machine, a sensor is added. SCADA records these states without manual entry by operators, so you can enter the actual hours worked instead of planned hours into the machine hour formula. In the same way, it records the number of units produced, on which the other calculations are based.
✅ MES assigns data to orders and products
MES is a system for monitoring and managing production. To the machine data, it adds which order and which product the machine is currently producing, why it is stopped and how many units failed inspection. Some of this information is entered by the operator directly at the machine as soon as the event occurs. A defective unit is thus recorded against the correct product and in the correct month. Instead of a company-wide average, you then know how much a specific product costs. At the same time, you can see which product or machine generates the most defects and focus your measures right there.
✅ OEE monitoring distinguishes the type of loss
OEE is the overall equipment effectiveness indicator, which combines three perspectives. Availability tells you how much of the planned time the machine worked, performance how fast it produced, and quality how many units were good. Lost time is thus broken down into downtime, reduced speed and defects, and measures can focus on the largest of these losses. Fixed costs cannot be reduced quickly, but they can be spread better. Shorter downtime adds operating hours, and faster operation with fewer defects adds good units in every hour.
✅ CMMS assigns interventions to a specific machine
Maintenance interventions can be recorded in a computerized maintenance management system, abbreviated as CMMS. Each intervention and spare part is recorded against a specific piece of equipment, so maintenance in the machine’s fixed costs is based on its own history, not on the cost center average. The history also reveals machines that are repeatedly repaired for the same fault. This makes it possible to decide, based on evidence, whether to eliminate the cause, change the regular servicing interval or replace the machine. Condition monitoring can also alert you to equipment deterioration before a breakdown occurs.
✅ EMS measures consumption by line, BMS controls the building
An EMS, or energy management system, tracks consumption by machine, line and hall over time. Energy thus changes from a cost allocated by floor area to a cost measured at a specific line or even a specific machine. The load profile shows consumption during non-production hours as well as peak loads. Heating, ventilation and lighting can then be set in the BMS, the system that controls building technologies, according to when the hall is actually in use. You verify the result through consumption per good unit.
✅ Reporting and BI combine data into a single overview
When production quantities are linked with prices from the company’s ERP system, management can see them in one place. Production, maintenance and management thus work with the same numbers for the same period. The situation before and after a measure can then be seen side by side. However, Business Intelligence tools, abbreviated as BI, do not collect data on their own. They only display what they receive, so the overview is only as complete as its inputs. And measurement alone does not reduce costs either. They are only reduced by a process in which data collection is followed by analysis, action and verification of results.
How to start measuring and reducing operating costs?
- Choose one machine or one line and calculate its costs. Use the data you already have and note for each input whether it is measured or estimated. The result is the baseline you will compare against later.
- Start measuring the inputs that are currently estimates. Most often, these are actual operating hours, defects or energy consumption. If the machine does not provide them itself, add a sensor or a meter.
- Compare the measured data with the estimates and repeat the calculation. After a few weeks, you will see how much the actual costs differ from those you have been working with so far, and which loss increases them the most.
- Choose a measure for the largest measured loss and verify its result. After the change, calculate the costs in the same way at a similar production volume.
- Extend the approach to other equipment only once the change has proven effective. Continue when the measure on the first machine has demonstrably reduced costs and the measured data is complete.
Do you want to know where your operating costs really come from?
Can you tell today which line, shift or product increased your costs last month? If not, book a no-obligation consultation and we will look at it together. At IoT Industries, we start with one machine or line, use the equipment and systems you already have, and introduce measurement with minimal disruption to ongoing production. Before you decide on the next step, you will see in your own numbers where your costs come from and what is worth changing.
Why Choose IoT/IIoT Implementation with IoT Industries?
Traditional companies typically specialize in OT (operational technologies, such as production lines and devices) or classic enterprise IT systems. However, we are able to connect both of these worlds. Our unique expertise in integrating OT and IT allows us to deliver innovative solutions in digital transformation, enhancing efficiency, reliability, and competitiveness for manufacturing companies.